How to check a mechanical takeoff before you bid
Before a mechanical takeoff goes into your bid, check that the scope matches your sheets, the counts agree with the schedules, every line traces back to the drawings, the addenda are included and the assumptions are written down. Here is the checklist, and a ten minute spot check you can run on any takeoff.
Short answer
Check five things: the scope matches the sheets you sent, the counts agree with the schedules, you can trace any line back to the drawings, the addenda are in, and the assumptions are written down. If a takeoff fails any of these, fix it or send it back before the number goes into your bid.
This checklist works whether the takeoff came from your own team, a junior estimator or an outside service.
The checklist
1. Scope and sheets
- Every sheet in your scope is listed, with its revision. Look for a sheet index.
- No sheets are missing: plans, enlarged plans, sections, details, schedules and the legend.
- The items you asked for are the items counted. "Air devices and equipment" is not the same scope as "full mechanical".
- Items outside the scope are excluded on purpose and listed as excluded, not just missing.
2. Counts against the schedules
- Every tag on the equipment and air device schedules appears in the takeoff.
- Every tag in the takeoff appears on a schedule. A tag on the plans with no schedule entry needs a question.
- Where the plan count and the schedule quantity differ, the takeoff says so and gives a reason.
- Sizes, neck sizes and CFM match the schedule for air devices, if you need them for a TAB bid.
3. Traceability
- Pick three lines at random. Can you find each counted item on the drawing in under a minute?
- For measured items, is there a markup showing what was measured, by size and system?
- Counts are broken down by floor or area, so you can check one floor instead of the whole building.
4. Addenda and revisions
- The takeoff names the addenda it includes.
- Revised sheets replaced the old ones, and nothing was counted twice.
- Schedules revised by addendum were re-read, not just the plans.
5. Notes, assumptions and scope flags
- General notes and keynotes that change the work are flagged: existing equipment to remain, equipment replacement, pre and post testing, pressure critical rooms.
- Typical callouts ("TYP") have a stated count, not a guess.
- Assumptions and exclusions are written, so they can go into your qualifications.
- Conflicts are listed as questions you can send as RFIs.
Measured scopes
Duct, piping and other measured scopes need a slightly different check. Ask for the markup that shows what was measured, and confirm that lengths are split by size, system or service the way you price them. Check that fittings, transitions and insulation are either counted or clearly excluded. Spot check one long run per system against the drawing scale. If the takeoff gives a single total footage per size with nothing behind it, you have no way to find an error short of measuring again.
Red flags
- Quantities that exactly match every schedule on a large set. It can happen, but it often means the schedule was copied.
- Round numbers on measured items with no markup behind them.
- No list of assumptions at all.
- No mention of addenda when you know some were issued.
- "Lump sum" lines where you expected counts.
A ten minute spot check
- Open the summary and compare the equipment list with the equipment schedule.
- Sort the lines by status or difference, and read every line where the plan count and schedule disagree.
- Pick one busy floor and count one device type yourself.
- Trace three random lines to the drawings.
- Read the assumptions and scope notes against the specification sections you have.
Keep notes as you go. Anything you change, carry or question during the check belongs in your qualifications or your RFI list, so the reason for each number is on paper when the bid is reviewed, and again if the job is awarded and the quantities are questioned later.
If those five steps pass, you can price the takeoff with confidence. If any fail, the takeoff needs work before it goes in your bid.
How our takeoffs are built for this check
Our count takeoffs are made to pass this list quickly. The workbook has Summary, Takeoff, Evidence, By category, Scope flags and Sheet index sheets. Every line shows the schedule quantity, the plan count and the final quantity, with a GREEN, YELLOW or RED status and the reason. The Evidence sheet lists the sheet, page and location of every counted item. A person reviews every RED and YELLOW line against the drawings before delivery. Download the sample takeoff and run the ten minute check on it.
For air balancing bids the schedule check matters even more, because every outlet is a test point. See takeoffs for air balancing (TAB) contractors.
Our prices
Our prices: a count takeoff of air devices and equipment starts at $245 for up to 10 sheets, then $20 per sheet. A measured trade takeoff starts at $325 per trade for up to 6 sheets, then $52 per sheet. Pricing with your own rates is from +$195. Every job gets a fixed quote before any work starts. See full pricing, or CAD prices for Canadian contractors.
Addenda issued before work starts are included. Addenda issued after delivery are re-run as a change: affected sheets at the per-sheet rate, minimum $75 USD. Send a set through the request form.
Checking a takeoff
How long should it take to check a takeoff?
For a count takeoff with an evidence list, spot checking a handful of lines and every red flag usually takes far less time than the count itself. If checking means recounting the whole set, the takeoff is missing its evidence.
What is the most important thing to check?
That equipment and air device counts agree with the schedules, or that every difference is explained. Disagreements are where bids are lost.
Should I trust schedule quantities?
Not on their own. Schedules can be out of date after an addendum, or have no quantity column at all. Counts should come from the plans and be compared with the schedules.
What should I do with a RED line?
Open the sheet it points to and decide: count it, carry it as an assumption, or send an RFI. Do not bid a red line without a decision.
Do your takeoffs come with evidence?
Yes. Every count takeoff has an Evidence sheet with the sheet, page and location of every counted item, and a GREEN, YELLOW or RED status on every line. Measured trades come with the Bluebeam markup PDF.
Do you include a marked-up drawing set for count takeoffs?
No. Count takeoffs list the location of each item in the Evidence sheet instead of highlighting it on the drawings.
Request a takeoff
Send the drawings and the scope. You get a fixed quote, usually within 1 business day, and nothing starts until you accept it and pay.